Consider this a companion peace to the earlier “Rights.”
I’ve noticed a recurring theme in many political discussions in which I’ve engaged, and what it boils down to is this: “How dare you criticize Bush when your hero, Bill Clinton, has done the same or worse.”
Putting aside that I’ve never said Clinton was my hero…indeed, putting aside that I’ve openly stated he embarrassed the office of the presidency…
…that makes it okay…how?
See, that’s what I don’t comprehend. Bush supporters spouting high dudgeon that he’s criticized for his actions when, of course, conservative pundits never said ANYTHING harsh about Clinton in the entire eight years of his presidency. Not a word, not a syllable.
Is anyone suffocating on the double standard? Because I certainly am.
Right on this board, it was stated, in referencing the Dixie Chicks, that Trent Lott was on solid ground suggesting Clinton’s bombing of Kosovo was a dodge to distract from impeachment proceedings, and how Lott was then being made to apologize. So why, too, shouldn’t the Dixie Chicks be made to apologize? Let us not even discuss that a passing remark by a singer is simply not comparable to an inflammatory prejudicial remark made by a senior member of a governing board about to pass judgment on the chief executive (tantamount to a judge saying, “The defendant’s hired a high price lawyer, probably to try and make him seem less guilty when he comes before me.”)
Instead let us ponder the double standard. Lott’s remark is understandable, acceptable. But opine that perhaps, maybe, Bush was motivated to go after Saddam because his vow to bring in Osama bin Laden “dead or alive” (remember that?) has proven fruitless and he’s worried it’ll hurt his re-election chances, and suddenly you’re showing unpatriotic disrespect for the office of the presidency.
The message is clear. Clinton was fair game. Bush isn’t, or at least shouldn’t be, because we’re at war. Which, it might be observed, is exactly the status that he craved. Keep the people off balance, keep them running scared, so they’ll be too afraid to make a change in 2004 (or, as one poster said in positively Bushian style, 2006.)
JFK, endeavoring to speak German, informed the people of Berlin, “I am a jelly doughnut.” That doesn’t make it okay that our current president can’t string two sentences together without it being an adventure. FDR signed a document consigning Japanese American citizens to prison camps. That doesn’t make beyond reproach the enacting of acts violating fundamental aspects of privacy and due process. I mean, how far back do you want to take it? Thomas Jefferson owned slaves. That’s MUCH worse than authorizing burglaries and covering them up, so Richard Nixon should never have resigned from office.
Someone asked me if I thought we’d have invaded Iraq if Gore were president. I’m thinking no. Why? Because even if he’d wanted to, Congress would never have given him the authority to do so. Besides, they’d be too busy with month eighteen of probes into the security lapses that allowed the destruction of the WTC and trying to blame it on him. My belief is that, rather than 9/11 defining his presidency, it would have been the trigger for attack dogs to have been let loose with one simple message: Terrorists think Gore is weak and therefore attacked us. This never would have happened with a Republican in the White House.
But blame Bush? Naaaah.
Double standard. Conjecture, granted…but not wholly without foundation, I think.
No one should be above consideration and criticism. And this attitude of trying to punish the critics or excuse the subject of criticism because others have allegedly done the same or worse, rather than giving thought to what’s being said…
…now THAT’S unAmerican.





Wow! That’s the best commentary on the situation I have read in a while.
I agree. Well done, Peter. The hypocrisy and double standards of the current people in power seems to know no bounds. It’s even worse considering much of it is illegal (like Bennett playing poker in Washington with a couple Supreme Court judges, punishable by up to 5 years in prison by D.C. law…)
Amen, brother Peter, Amen.
One correction, though: JFK gets a bad rap on the “jelly doughut” thing. Truth is, his words were entirely correct for local usage. Here’s a link for further clarification:
http://urbanlegends.about.com/library/weekly/aa021700a.htm
This oft-repeated error doesn’t change the essential truth of your analysis about the double standard that the Bush administration currently enjoys. (I personally think his linquistic misadventures are beside the point, and may well be indicative of boderline dsylexia or other mild learning disability–certainly nothing to be mocked, and nothing with any bearing on his intelligence and capabilities. There’s plenty of other, more important, evidence that can and should be used to weigh those things.)
Can anyone seriously claim that Clinton (or Gore, for that matter) wouldn’t have been (justly) derided for play-acting their Commander-in-Chief/Top-Gun fantasies the way Bush did last week, to take one small example?
What’s truly astounding is that Rove & Co. didn’t even try to pass it off as anything other than what it was: a campaign commercial in the making. That’s how confident they are in the fact that we’ve all given in to such things, that we’re too tired, too confused, and too anxious for our bûllšhìŧ detectors to function anymore.
Where’s Spider Jerusalem when you need him?
I guess what bothers me the most is the notion that somebody should be targeted and punished for criticizing the president. Don’t people in this country understand how important criticism of the president is, regardless of political affiliation, ESPECIALLY, not excepting, in wartime?
War is the most serious action a nation can undertake. Even if the president was right, there should always be some people criticizing him as ferociously as possible, just to keep him on the straight and narrow. That’s a must for all political leaders. If a political leader becomes too popular, or opposing voices are silenced, he is free to do anything, including things for his personal gain that may not be in the best interests of of the nation.
So why on Earth would anyone who values our American way of life want to punish someone for criticizing the president? They should be thanking them for performing an essential service to democracy.
Heck, Bob Barr was out to get Clinton, but that didn’t mean Clinton’s hands were clean, and despite my disagreement with Barr’s political leanings, I am glad there was someone keeping the most powerful man in the world in check.
That’s how our system works. Politicians are kept from getting away with bad stuff because there is always someone after them. On the few times when people did get away with bad stuff (see FDR’s internment camps) it was when they were overwhelmingly popular and people followed them unquestioningly.
First of all, I really enjoyed reading that, PAD. That made me think.
Second, when was the last politician that wasn’t hypocritical?
Totally agree, Peter, but I’m sure there will be those that cannot get past their political high-horse to admit that many in this country have gone into knee-jerk “shrieking in the night” hysterics whenever someone forms an opinion that differs from their own.
I have no problem with the idea that people say, “Well, I support the president,” or, “I don’t agree with what that Dixie Chick singer said, so I’m not buying her album.” It’s when you get into the “shoot that Dixie Chick blankety-blank in the face because she’s supporting Saddam . . . and if you disagree then you’re just trying to take away my freedom of speech . . . so shut up!” that the problem comes into play.
But, on to the other point of this essay – when a political leader does something wrong, the first reaction of his or her supporters is, “well, everyone else did it, so why are you bothering here?” Of course, the main point is that we shouldn’t accept outrageous behavior from anyone in a political office, be it Clinton lying or Bush with Iraq.
People who have a problem with Tim Robbins or the Dixie Chicks seem to have stuck themselves on a retoric that says, “saying something has consequences.” But so do actions. And why are we excusing the actions of our political leaders as if it’s okay if they do it, but not okay if some two-bit singer of a band says something?
How ironic that this subject would garner my first post. PAD you’ve simply hit the nail on the head in this commentary. As a guy who spent far too many years of his life studying political science I find it incredible how the GOP has been able to stymie dissent by questioning people’s patriotism. I’m not surprised but I am truly disgusted.
Now can you tell me just what the hëll happened on Alias last night?
Very well-spoken, Peter. I only think it’s a shame that anyone has to be so eloquent when explaining the simplest of concepts such as this.
Incidentally, I’ve had a thought about the war situation. I realized that, knowing what I know to the level of certainty that I do, I can’t honestly say I don’t know for a fact that Bush isn’t sincere in his efforts over the last few months. I can’t rule out the possibility that Bush genuinely believes that Saddam Hussein is a threat to the free world, and that the possibility of his getting weapons of mass destruction keeps Bush up at night. It doesn’t really conflict with anything I know, and it even makes sense in light of the world’s reaction to him; he’s such a terrible speaker that I have no trouble believing he can’t convince anyone of anything, no matter how passionately he feels it. I have suspicions and other possibilities that are equally plausible, to be sure, but I don’t know anything that rules out the possibility.
Of course, the likelyhood of that being the case is rather low, I just can’t disprove it. As for critics of the president, I think they’ve become a bit more vicious than is really called for, but it’s not like it’s had any effect on his campaign at all.
Now can you tell me just what the hëll happened on Alias last night?
Nothing that *I* expected, I can tell you.
PAD
The reason I brought up Trent Lott was because somebody said someone criticizing Clinton would not have come under the same pressure. My point was that someone did criticize Clinton and had come under the same pressure. My point was not that what happened with the Dixie Chicks was a good thing. (And if you want to talk about inflammatory prejudicial remarks, how about the attempts by Senator Daschle and others to get pledges not to convict Clinton no matter what?)
Frankly, what annoys me as a conservative is the double standard. In answer to what would have happened if Clinton had “play-acted Top Gun fantasies”, the fact is that Clinton *did* do the same thing Bush did, except that Clinton’s entourage then looted the aircraft carrier involved. It goes on and on. Clinton not going to Vietnam, fine. Bush not going to Vietnam, terrible reflection on his character. Republicans criticizing Clinton? They must have a pathological hatred of the man. Democrats critizing Bush? How dare the Republicans question their patriotism by denouncing the criticisms!
In any case, go ahead and criticize Bush as much as you want. I just wish it was at a higher level than “Bush is a dolt” or “Ashcroft is a Nazi”.
Kudos Peter! Does indeed sound as close to a modern display of McCarthyism as ever. I just hope we don’t see history repeat itself with another “House of Un-American Activities Committee”.
Somewhat off-topic but this reminds me of one of the things people do to deflect criticism that always baffles me: Guy A smokes. Guy B says that smoking is bad for you and Guy A should quit. Guy A responds by saying, “Guy B said I shouldn’t smoke but he was/is a smoker!” I’ve never understood how that makes the point any less true. (And I’m probably stating the obvious here but my point isn’t smoking, it’s whatever people ignore by saying “But you/he/they do it too.”)
I guess we just love our vices and it’s hard to admit being wrong but I’ve never understood why people think that response, “Yeah but you used to drink” or whatever, ends the argument.
**First of all, I really enjoyed reading that, PAD. That made me think.
Second, when was the last politician that wasn’t hypocritical?**
Hard to say. Kind of liked McCain, actually.
PAD
It goes on and on. Clinton not going to Vietnam, fine. Bush not going to Vietnam, terrible reflection on his character.
Okay, see, that’s my point. Right there. Those two sentences.
“Clinton not going to Vietnam, fine.” Fine? On what planet, “fine?” Conservatives bashed him for him. Called him a draft dodger. Used it to impugn him six ways from Sunday. “Bush not going to Vietnam.” Okay, enlighten me. Did the conservative pundits hammer Bush for that? Because I’m thinking not.
PAD
I find it funny that peter is getting kudos for basicaly saying that the sky is blue and that fire is hot.
I had to remind the Clinton supporters that complained when I would say he was an all around bad guy, that I had to sit and listen to them pointing out Regan and Bush Sr. faults. (Ðámņ, I wish Regan hadn’t dealt with Iran contra, he would have been one of the best presidents ever.)
War? What “war.” This is worse the the Grenada B.S., I’m watch a 12 grader kick the hëll out of a first grader and everyone keeps saying “we are at war.”
First of all we have been bombing, security fact finding, accusing Saddam since the first bush, who help put Saddam in office well running the CIA. Secondly, I have never bought the “Saddam is a threat to America.” And no one has reasonably showed exactly what the threat is and how it manifests. As far as I know there is no information on the people that flew those planes into those building being from Iraq.
And about those planes. Why is everyone simply buying into this story? In the Airforce I worked as a “Ground to Air Radio Communications Specialist” – I swear that’s what they called it. What I actually did was provide fast maintenance for various control rooms within a specific division as part of a 30 man plus crew, or replaced walkie talkies when they broke (I know, I felt like a technical wizard, I tell you.) I have been in a few Airport control towers. Now, one plane suddenly going in another direction, Okay I’m with you. Two planes, okay, maybe (where Willis when you need him.) But wasn’t it (and please correct me if I am wrong) four planes that got jacked? Two hit the towers, one was force down and one hit washington. And no one, NO ONE, is asking how does four plane suddenly change directly, stop radio communication and it took the towers being hit to alert anyone? You mean all that radar and satellite and beacons built into planes were worth nothing on that day? You should see a control room when ONE plane goes off course even slightly. I am still trying to grasp how four did it and no one was aware until well after the fact.
Yet Americans keep buying the “we are at war” with a country that barely has weapons because WE KEEP BOMBING THEM. Yet Americans simply except that these men just took 4 planes and everyone was unware of all those major course changes and sudden radio silences. Its beginning to sound like a plot from a bad Avengers issue. I keep expecting Hydra to jump out and announce their “Make Americans Stupid” ray has been a success. At least with that senario we know Captain America will eventualy destroy it.
I recently stumbled upon a quote by a past president that really says a lot about how the political discourse in this country used to be.
“To announce that there must be no criticism of the president, or that we are to stand by the president right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile, but is morally treasonable to the American public.” — Theodore Roosevelt
I think ole Teddy got it right.
Oh, and just in case anyone is buying into the notion that Clinton got some sort of free pass on Vietnam while Bush was heavily criticized, this from “thestraightdope.com”:
“A few months after the 2000 election, former Bill Clinton adviser Paul Begala said he’d done a Nexis search and found 13,641 stories about Clinton’s alleged draft dodging versus 49 about George W. Bush’s military record.”
PAD
Sorry to post twice so quickly, but PAD just reminded me of a great book. It’s called “What LIberal Media?” by Eric Alterman. It goes into great detail that the idea of the liberal media is, in fact, a useful myth perpetrated by conservatives to try and “play the refs” so they get the good calls.
The book goes into deep details about the extremely conservative slant of the punditocracy and makes a good point that what we in America consider to be liberal or left would, in most countries of Western Europe be considered, at best, centrist.
Alterman also makes the point that Bush got the presidential honeymoon that Clinton never did because there was not an organized, rabid liberal group poised and ready to begin villifying him the moment he took office.
Peter, you tricked me into only reading the statement on the main page. I thought that was it funny that the others were congradulating you on that small snippet. You make some good points that could be debated for many a long hour. I have no dout that GWB wanted to get Iraq because of his dad’s participation in the gulf war in 91. Do I think that is wrong or bad? Not in the least. We had many reasons to go back to Iraq, the first being that the war never officialy ended.
I find it funny that peter is getting kudos for basicaly saying that the sky is blue and that fire is hot.
When Chicken Little is running the country, pointing out that the sky isn’t falling starts to look intelligent.
–Daniel M.
Here’s the main difference in the whole Clinton/Bush Vietnam thing.
Clinton wrote a letter saying he despised the military. Then while president, Clinton slashed funding for the military. But, he would use them for a war that was not sanctioned by the UN Security Council or the congress (sound familiar?).
Bush joined the Air National Guard and learned to fly jets. Granted the Guard unit was one of the last that would ever be called to fight, but he was there. And no matter that he isn’t the best public speaker without his notes, they just don’t allow unintelligent people to fly fighter planes. It doesn’t matter who’s son they are.
So it’s no wonder there weren’t as many articles about Bush as there were Clinton.
The moral difference between Clinton and Bush on Vietnam was that Clinton opposed the war and didn’t want anyone (including himself) to go. Bush supported the war but was unwilling to put himself in the line of fire. Bush was happy to let blacks, hispanics, and poor southern whites die for America. Clearly, the moral high ground here is owned by Gore who opposed the war and could have dodged but could not handle the thought of some other Tennesseean being sent in his place…
On the main topic here, “Why was it OK to criticise Clinton but not Bush?” – The major moral justification for government is that sometimes it provides protection for the weak from the power of the rich and powerful. Since the Republicans are the party of the rich and powerful, they have no problem acting in ways that undermine the legitimacy of government. The Dems are the party of government. They are restricted in their words and behaviour by a desire to preserve the system.
Okay Peter, you got me. I wasn’t being precise enough.
What I meant was that *liberals* didn’t think there was any problem with Clinton avoiding the draft, but they did think there was a problem with Bush being in the Air National Guard. I thought that was an obvious implication but I guess I was mistaken.
Denver_Jay — The problem I have with your analysis is that it is now the government that is the rich and powerful. As for Gore, I think that his decision to enlist was in part to help with his father’s reelection campaign. That’s also why Nixon delayed the younger Gore’s actually being sent to Vietnam.
As for there not being the a rabid liberal group vilifying Bush from the moment he took office, are you serious? There are still people claiming that he stole the election and occupies the Oval Office fraudulently.
Robert wrote:
Frankly, what annoys me as a conservative is the double standard. In answer to what would have happened if Clinton had “play-acted Top Gun fantasies”, the fact is that Clinton *did* do the same thing Bush did, except that Clinton’s entourage then looted the aircraft carrier involved.
Can you cite the relevant press reports, please? I’m not aware of Clinton ever playing co-pilot in a jet which did a risky tailhook landing on an aircraft carrier, but perhaps I missed something.
(It’s worth noting, I think, that the carrier in question for Bush’s commercial last week in fact had to delay its already long-overdue trip home by a few more hours to make the stunt possible, and had to reverse direction to do so, which cost time, money, and fuel. Not that we need to worry about that last bit anymore, I suppose.)
Robert wrote:
It goes on and on. Clinton not going to Vietnam, fine.
Wha? What planet were you on in ’92? It wasn’t fine, and wasn’t treated as such. He was justly raked over the coals for it, people were given the facts, and they made their choice with those facts well and truly in the context.
Robert wrote:
Bush not going to Vietnam, terrible reflection on his character.
Not necessarily. How he got into the Texas NG is a terrible reflection on his character, as is the way he dishcharged, or failed to, the full extent of his obligations. It hasn’t been reported nearly as widely as Clinton’s own weasling was, becuase Bush has been given a pass on the issue becuase we’re “at war”. On the level of personal character, one wishes that a President with his particular spotty service record would refrain from doing the kind of thing he did last week, but that would require a capacity for self-awareness I’m not sure he possesses. In that sense, he’s much like his predecessor.
Robert wrote:
In any case, go ahead and criticize Bush as much as you want. I just wish it was at a higher level than “Bush is a dolt” or “Ashcroft is a Nazi”.
Whom are you quoting? PAD certainly didn’t use those remarks in his commentary, nor did I in the post you responded to. I realize it’s easier to argue with straw men, but it’s not on a particularly high level, if that’s what you’re truly seeking.
The Dems are the party of government. They are restricted in their words and behaviour by a desire to preserve the system.
You know, I would usually agree with you there, but actually Dubya has increased the power of the government a hëll of a lot since he has been in office.
Jeff: Then while president, Clinton slashed funding for the military.
True, but he also always signed in the annual raise the military askd for without blinking. Something Dubya took his time on in his first year.
Rick:”To announce that there must be no criticism of the president, or that we are to stand by the president right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile, but is morally treasonable to the American public.” — Theodore Roosevelt
I think ole Teddy got it right.
And so do I. Teddy is one of my heroes. But he also preformed a wonderful version of hypocrisy (which is why he probably only was elected for one term)… he took money from anyone, and then did what he felt was right, dámņ the torpedoes and anyone who thinks differently. Love that man… between him and Truman, those were the last great presidents.
War? What “war.” This is worse the the Grenada B.S., I’m watch a 12 grader kick the hëll out of a first grader and everyone keeps saying “we are at war.”
Fairly funny… and I doubt it could be considered a war, since congress is the only one who can proclaim war.
Robert:In any case, go ahead and criticize Bush as much as you want. I just wish it was at a higher level than “Bush is a dolt” or “Ashcroft is a Nazi”.
Actually, I agree here too Robert. If we need to criticize, don’t name call. Specifics please. When we name call, we show our intelligence, or lack thereof.
And on another note, calling someone a Nazi is really pushing the limits, don’t you think?
I mean, the nazi’s mass slaughtered helpless victims in concentration camps, taking their gold, riches, etc to push on their war. But more importantly, it was an ethnic cleansing.
To call the actions of the Dubya administration akin to Nazism is really lessening the horrors of what happend to the Jewish people. Or at least in my mind.
Anyway, those are my thoughts.
Travis
PAD, you’ve touched on something that is very true. This is a complicated subject, but in my experience, bashing Bush immediately means you support Clinton.
Well, fact is, Clinton was not a good president – he was just good at looking like one. This is a guy who, on his rise to power, was allegedly involved in the drug trade in the 80’s; had more than 80 people killed to cover it up, and as president did a lot of things that I’m sure Bush and his lot didn’t object to, like cut back on fuel efficiency in cars – the first president to do so since Nixon, I believe.
No, Clinton was not a good guy. Bush however is even worse. It’s sad and scary that people refuse to see that. It’s even more frightening to see them get defensive and insulting toward those who have the courage to say anything about it.
I’m going to do some blog commentary on this very subject at my blog… feel free to visit. Yes, I guess this is an advertisement.
“We had many reasons to go back to Iraq, the first being that the war never officialy ended.”
Actually, I’m not sure that a war ever officially started. According to the Constitution, only Congress can declare war. To the best of my knowledge, this has not happened since WWII. It could be argued that all wars following that one are unconstitutional. I know in some cases Congress has given its unofficial blessing for a President to start a war, but that is an unconstitutional act by Congress. I wish that if Congressmen were going to support a war they would actually have the guts to Declare one. I know they figure that they can just shirk the responsiblity and blame the Presiedent if things go badly, but how gutless is that? If they truly believe in a war they should Declare one, if they don’t have the sack to do so, then we shouldn’t be starting one period.
“To call the actions of the Dubya administration akin to Nazism is really lessening the horrors of what happend to the Jewish people. Or at least in my mind.
Anyway, those are my thoughts.
Travis”
I don’t think that is most people’s intent when they call Bush a Nazi. I believe they are referring to the Nazi desire to conquer the World and to take away peoples’ freedoms. I haven’t heard too many people in this country accusing Bush of ethnic cleansing of any kind.
I don’t believe that he embraces the Nazi party myself so it is an inaccurate discription and is a poorly phrased arguement.
He does however have a lot of people on his Cabinet that are members of the Project for the New American Century. Check it out if you are curious about some of the President’s Cabinet’s agenda.
http://www.newamericancentury.org/
As a small ‘l’ libertarian (not affiliated with the wacky politicians that seem to use the name so much), I get to sit in the middle and watch when these things change. I’m glad PAD pointed it out.
Actually, in recent months, my favorite switch like this was in the opposite direction (note: I’m not arguing against anything PAD said, just pointing out another example).
From the previous eight years, I’m used to hearing “liberal media” and “liberal bias” and the like. When it came to the events in Iraq, the opposite side was suddenly condemning the “right wing media” and “conservative bias” of the reporting. Same media…same reporters…but somehow switched from liberal to conservative by those that disagreed with them.
is there anyone who disagrees? Because I’m starting to feel awfully alone here.
First off there is a differnce between Bush and the people who bash the dixie chicks and robbins. Cheney has even says that he thinks the term Freedom fries is ridiculous and I have heard no comment by the administration as to the dixie chicks deserving all of this. The first amendment doesn’t mean that you can say anything and there will be no repercusions. It just means that you are free to say it and not be imprisoned for it. Bush isn’t the one sending the deaththreats, try to keep that in mind.
The only time I ever heard the administration try to shut people up is when Ari said we had to “watch what we say” and the backlash cost Bill Maher his job.That was out of line.
Second hollywood has always always been strongly liberal, most conservatives are afraid to speak out because they think they will not get hired again. I’m not complaining, this does not violate the first amendment.
Since I am the only one to oppose you guys let me reccomend and author and book. Larry Elder’s
Ten things you can’t say in America is very interesting reading. Give it a shot he’s not a conservative or liberal.
Talking about the “liberal media” DOES make me chuckle….
It’s certainly true that 90% of the working stiff journalists are liberal….but it’s also certainly true that 95%+ of the media ownership is very conservative. (You really think the Hearsts and Otis Chandler were bleeding heart liberals?). Either the ownership are being fools in their hiring, or their priorities aren’t just ideological partisanship….
An awful lot of the liberal critics (not all. Not even necessarily most.) seem to regard any disagreement with their views as the equivilent of censorship. So we are left with the sorry sight of some actor showing up on a cable news network and kvetching about how his views are being stymied. Right. Only 8 million people watching, wow, positively Stalinistic this muzzling of dissent.
Anyway, for 8 years critics of Clinton got called all sorts of names. We took it as a badge of honor. So suck it up and give old GW your best shot–maybe history will prove you right too.
Here’s a strategic tip, freely given as it will almost certainly be ignored–never paint your opponent as an idiot. Because if he beats you (which is where the smart money (not Bill Bennett) would go, given that sorry debate among the Democrats night the last)you become the “one who got his ášš handed to him by an idiot”. See Gore, Al, the first 2 debates, for a good example.
Anyway, thank God the politics are back on peterdavid.net. With the war going so well and the predictions of hundreds of thousands of dead so off I was worried it’d be nothing but Buffy and Angel reviews. Not that this would be an altogether bad thing…
“Second hollywood has always always been strongly liberal, most conservatives are afraid to speak out because they think they will not get hired again.”
I love when people say this, especially given that there’s not even one interview I’ve ever heard of affirming this attitude, let alone real documented evidence of anything.
I’t bogus, a catch-phrase argument from the right ‘about’ Hollywood that has no basis in anything.
The only time in history where blackballing in Hollywood happened based on politics was hardly an attack from the left on the right.
Message to liberals, libertarians, and independents – No amount of reasoned discussion will convice an opponent who’s only intent is TO BEAT YOU. You think you are in some universal pursuit of truth. They ALREADY HAVE whatever truth they want, now all they need is VICTORY. You’ll support THEIR position if convinced it leads to a better world. Good for you. But they will attack and attack and attack and attack YOUR position REGARDLESS, and wouldn’t support your man if Hëll Froze Over. On their side it is a cold, simple world where THEY are RIGHT and YOU are WRONG and the only choices are FOR them or AGAINST them.
Any jingoistic conservative can raise an army of dittohead automatons in a heartbeat to pump up their ratings, book sales and poll results. Unfortunately, the rest of us only wake up when things have fallen facefirst into the çráppër.
Well, I don’t know about you guys, but my hair’s wet, and I don’t like the way it smells.
For what its worth–as I recall–war was declared in 1991 & if I’m not mistaken there was never a declaration of peace.
An awful lot of the liberal critics (not all. Not even necessarily most.) seem to regard any disagreement with their views as the equivilent of censorship
I don’t think that disagreement is the issue. The issue was and is how critics of the war(and of Bush for that matter) are portrayed/handled my the media. Since September 11 the media has basically rolled over for the administration they should probably get their own cabinet seat. There is very little criticism or investigation by major media outlets. Why? Maybe they’re afraid of being accused of being disloyal, maybe they’re afraid the GOPTV I mean Fox News will begin harping about the great liberal media, or maybe they figure the best way to make a buck isn’t to be a skeptic but rather be a cheerleader. Take any of the big three 24hour cable news networks and look at how they question any Bush people. It’s almost always in an accusatory tone. Compare that to the softballs administration officials get and anyone can see that if you’re going to oppose this president you have to be prepared for a hostile environment.
Take any of the big three 24hour cable news networks and look at how they question any Bush people
That should read anti-Bush people of course.
For what its worth–as I recall–war was declared in 1991 & if I’m not mistaken there was never a declaration of peace.
As another poster comented there hasn’t been a declaration of war by the US since 1941. The 1990 vote was an authorization of use of force under the auspices of the UN. A conflict that was ended by the cease-fire in 1991.
**”Second hollywood has always always been strongly liberal, most conservatives are afraid to speak out because they think they will not get hired again.”
I love when people say this, especially given that there’s not even one interview I’ve ever heard of affirming this attitude, let alone real documented evidence of anything.**
http://archive.salon.com/people/feature/2000/09/12/gopstars/index.html
http://www.uncommonknowledge.org/01-02/615.html
Well, now you have at least two. Enjoy.
Sigh… It’s seems like people are reacting like PAD has unlocked a magical secret or provided a some sort of new revelation. This sort of double standard crap happens on both sides of the political fence all of the time. It’s nothing new. Both sides have always served a nice helping of double standards and will continue to do so.
The news media may be owned by 95% conservative organizations (I don’t know that it is, and I would guess it isn’t) but the proof of the pudding is in the eating, as they say. What percentage of newspaper endorsements did Al Gore get in 2000 compared with the 48.5% of the popular vote he got? How many of the weekend news shows are being run by former Democratic politicos? How many Republican presidential candidates got invited by a top journalism school to teach a class on a subject they know nothing about, as Al Gore did?
Yes, Fox News is a conservative organization, but CBS, ABC, CCN, and to a lesser extent NBC are demonstrably liberal. Otherwise they wouldn’t hire people like George Stephanopolous to head up their weekend news shows. Then there is the New York Times, which invited Lawrence Eagleburger to write an Op-Ed about the war in Iraq but only if it were critical of the Bush Administration.
The whole “media is owned by corportations which are conservative so the media are conservative” argument just doesn’t hold water.
Um, neither of those articles show any example of someone being held down or refused work or being oppressed based on their right-leaning politics.
Are there a lot of liberals in Hollywood? Well, duh … but that’s not the issue. Bo Derek may think Hollywood liberals are close-minded and obstinant to deal with but she never even hinted that her being conservative has affected her career. Same with Selleck and the rest of them.
Here’s the main difference in the whole Clinton/Bush Vietnam thing.
Clinton wrote a letter saying he despised the military. Then while president, Clinton slashed funding for the military. But, he would use them for a war that was not sanctioned by the UN Security Council or the congress (sound familiar?).
Not quite. He wrote a letter to a Colonel whose recommendation would have put Clinton in a ROTC deferment (which he eventually turned down and allowed himself to be put into the draft). In it, he articulated how he despised the war in Vietnam and advanced his idea that the Vietnam draft was illegitimate (“No government really rooted in limited, parliamentary democracy should have the power to make its citizens fight and kill and die in a war they may oppose, a war which even possibly may be wrong, a war which, in any case, does not involve immediately the peace and freedom of the nation.”) He never expressed any hatred for the military at all. Check it out at http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/clinton/etc/draftletter.html
And although he reduced military spending, he certainly did not gut it. The US forces that were so effective in Afganistan and Iraq were, in all meaningful ways, Clinton’s military. And he did not slash veterans benefits (like the current president has).
His use of forces in Serbia, although controversial, at least had a goodly amount of international support (more than the current conflict, was diplomatically assembled, and did not alienate virtually every country on Earth), was not nearly as involved (I don’t even think there are any American soldiers peacekeeping in Serbia), did not try to claim that this war was anything besides a humanitarian effort (and that Mislovenic [sp?] was a madman who had to be stopped), and did not involve questionable rebuilding contracts.
Bush joined the Air National Guard and learned to fly jets. Granted the Guard unit was one of the last that would ever be called to fight, but he was there. And no matter that he isn’t the best public speaker without his notes, they just don’t allow unintelligent people to fly fighter planes. It doesn’t matter who’s son they are.
Bush joined the National Guard after scoring the lowest possible passing grade for pilot aptitude, but somehow polevaulted over more qualified applicants to get to the head of a year-and-a-half long waiting list.
And although he learned to fly jets, he, to be polite, didn’t do it often. Apparently, he was AWOL for the last 18 months of service and got away with it. http://www.boston.com/news/politics/campaign2000/news/One_year_gap_in_Bush_s_Guard_duty+.shtml
And though I agree that being a poor public speaker has no bearing on intelligence (Thomas Jefferson, IIRC, had someone else read the State of the Union since he had no talent for it), you don’t have to be brilliant, or even bright to fly a plane. And considering that Bush apparently didn’t fly at all for the last year-and-a-half of his service, that’s a non-issue.
So it’s no wonder there weren’t as many articles about Bush as there were Clinton.
It’s not a wonder, it’s a outstanding lapse.
Clinton wrote a letter thanking a colonel for recommending him for a ROTC post that might have kept him out of Vietnam, but apologized to him for not thoroughly expressing his views and stated his opposition to the war. He ultimately had his name put into the draft but had a high lottery number.
Bush, on the other hand, apparently had his well-connected father get him in the Texas National Guard (utterly avoiding Vietnam), and then disappeared for over a year and a half — an action that, for most people, leads to charges of desertion/AWOL, a court martial, and imprisonment followed by dishonorable discharge.
Why Bush got a free pass for that missing 18 months of his life, I cannot begin to fathom.
**No one should be above consideration and criticism. And this attitude of trying to punish the critics or excuse the subject of criticism because others have allegedly done the same or worse, rather than giving thought to what’s being said…
…now THAT’S unAmerican.**
Not at all. That’s human nature. You want to respond with something intelligent, but instead you respond with an “Oh yeah? Well, your side does it too!”
I’ve fallen prey to it. I’m reasonably sure that you have as well. Ðámņ, just did it again, didn’t I?
Seriously though, the whole premise of Freedom of Speech hinges on being free to speak your mind without fear of reprisal from the government.
THAT’s what was so reprehensible about the McCarthy hearings. The blacklisting that resulted was in response to the fear of the Government coming after people for their association with “questionable” people.
That’s why I have a problem with the hypocrisy of SAG. SAG, is mandated by LAW, which in effect, makes it a “blacklist” of sorts. You HAVE to join within thirty days of getting an acting job in Hollywood, whether you want to or not, unless your acting gig was a one time thing. You have to pay to join, and if you don’t join, anyone hiring you will be retaliated against.
To those who say Bush failed to get international support for the Iraq war, I have a question:
Under what circumstances do you think France would have supported a Security Council resolution supporting regime change, and if the answer is none, under which circumstances would it be acceptable to go to war against Iraq anyway?
Myself, I doubt anything short of Hans Blix finding nuclear weapons aimed at Paris would have brought France on board, and the reason is France supported Saddam Hussein.
“Um, neither of those articles show any example of someone being held down or refused work or being oppressed based on their right-leaning politics.”
Ok, did you actually read the articles? While it did not list movies they were refused or sitcoms that were cancelled, at least one of the articles clearly said that the actors believed that they were being held back due to their conservative views. The article does state it being true, it just does not list specific examples.
Anyways, I am glad to see so many people (Peter David included) underestimating the inteligence of Pres. Bush. It means he is even more likely to reelected.
The real difference between Clinton and Bush is that Bush actually means and does what he says. He is not perfect, and I would agree with some criticisms (such as the National Guard issue). But as a Texan, I have seen Bush conduct himself in private in a way that is consistent with what he claims to value. You may disagree with his values — that is your consitutional right! — but you are a fool to think he is prmiarily motivated by polls or public opinion (as his going to war without strong support demonstrated). Take the time to argue his views, and at least you will be dealing with reality.
So until “Q” declares himself as the next independent candidate, I will vote for Bush.
Granted the Guard unit was one of the last that would ever be called to fight, but he was there.
See, now…that’s the thing. He wasn’t. From what I read, he didn’t report for National Guard duty for seventeen months. In short, he was AWOL for a year and a half. When running for the presidency, he *claimed* he reported. But nto a shred of paperwork backs that up, and not a single one of the men he supposedly served with can verify it.
PAD
What I meant was that *liberals* didn’t think there was any problem with Clinton avoiding the draft, but they did think there was a problem with Bush being in the Air National Guard.
No, liberals thought there was problem with Clinton being crucified for trying to avoid the draft while Bush apparently went AWOL from 1971-72 from the National Guard and the story was ignored by most of the media.
PAD
Yeah, I read the articles. In those cases the writer implies that Derek hasn’t gotten work due to her politics, she makes no such assertions. In fact the story, quotes her, then makes its own assertions about why she’s not getting work, then quotes her again in a vague tangent that doesn’t say anything. Same with Selleck, he makes some statements about his politics, then the article writer says that it must be what’s keeping Selleck at bay, even though Selleck himself doesn’t say it or imply it, other than to say it’s easier to be liberal in Hollywood which again goes in the ‘duh’ column of reasoning.
You’d think if there were some legitimately black-balled performer out there that they’d go to Bill O’Reilly and Rush Limbaugh and at least mention it, it’s not like they’d fear being blacklisted if they already were in the first place.
Sorry, I don’t buy the argument. If Bo Derek were to assert that her politics were the cause of her decline in popularity and work (ignoring her constant personal problems and her difficulty to work with) she’d have no stronger case than Alec Baldwin would, another many would say annoyingly outspoken actor who’s star isn’t as bright today as it was 5 years ago.
There’s just no evidence, nor even a real voice saying it enough to make it seem like an issue.